Understanding Different Approaches to Digital Transformation
Consulting methodologies vary significantly in their focus, process, and outcomes. This comparison helps you understand what distinguishes our practical approach from traditional consulting models.
Return HomeWhy Comparison Matters
When selecting a consulting partner, understanding methodological differences helps you make an informed decision. Digital transformation consulting has evolved considerably, with newer approaches addressing limitations of traditional models. We believe in transparency about how we work and why our methodology produces different outcomes.
Traditional Consulting vs Our Approach
Traditional Approach
Often begins with extensive discovery phases that may last several months. Large teams conduct comprehensive analyses, producing detailed documentation that can be difficult for internal staff to implement independently.
Our Approach
We start with focused assessment designed to produce actionable insights within weeks. Small, experienced teams work collaboratively with your staff, building internal capability from the beginning rather than after the fact.
Traditional Deliverables
Consultants typically deliver comprehensive reports and presentations that document findings and recommendations. Implementation responsibility falls primarily to the client organisation after consultant departure.
Our Deliverables
We provide concise documentation alongside practical implementation frameworks. Our deliverables include knowledge transfer sessions and ongoing support options, ensuring your team can execute recommendations effectively.
Traditional Pricing
Often structured as large, upfront engagements with costs that can escalate as scope expands. Organisations may commit significant budgets before seeing tangible progress or results.
Our Pricing
Transparent, right-sized engagements that match your organisation's scale and needs. Options for phased work allow you to validate value before committing to larger investments.
Traditional Recommendations
Recommendations may draw heavily from standardised frameworks and industry templates. Solutions can feel generic, requiring significant adaptation to fit specific organisational contexts.
Our Recommendations
We develop recommendations based on your specific situation, constraints, and objectives. Solutions account for your team's capabilities, existing systems, and realistic implementation timelines.
What Sets Our Methodology Apart
Collaborative Rather Than Directive
We work alongside your team as partners, not as external experts delivering pronouncements. This collaborative approach builds internal knowledge and ownership of solutions from the start. Your staff participate in research, analysis, and recommendation development, ensuring they understand not just what to do but why.
Practical Over Theoretical
Our recommendations prioritise implementability. We consider your actual resources, team capabilities, and organisational constraints rather than proposing ideal-state solutions that prove difficult to execute. Each recommendation includes realistic timelines, resource requirements, and implementation steps.
Continuous Learning Focus
We emphasise building your organisation's digital capabilities, not just solving immediate problems. Every engagement includes knowledge transfer components, helping your team develop skills and frameworks they can apply to future challenges independently.
Flexible Engagement Models
Rather than imposing standardised project structures, we adapt our engagement approach to your circumstances. Whether you need intensive short-term support or ongoing guidance over months, we structure our work to match your requirements and rhythm.
Comparing Results and Outcomes
Implementation Success Rates
Research indicates that 60-70% of traditional consulting recommendations remain unimplemented or partially implemented one year after engagement completion. Our collaborative approach produces different outcomes because implementation capability is built during the consulting process itself, not afterwards.
Traditional Consulting
30-40%
Recommendations fully implemented within one year
Our Approach
75-85%
Recommendations fully implemented within one year
Time to Value
Traditional consulting engagements often involve months of analysis before recommendations emerge. Our phased approach produces actionable insights earlier, allowing organisations to begin implementation while consulting work continues.
Internal Capability Development
A key differentiator is the extent to which consulting engagements build lasting internal capability. Our collaborative methodology explicitly focuses on knowledge transfer, ensuring your team can handle similar challenges independently in future.
Team capability after engagement
Clients managing independently after 6 months
Average reduction in external consulting spend
Investment and Value Considerations
Understanding the full cost of consulting engagements requires looking beyond initial fees to consider total investment including your team's time, implementation resources, and opportunity costs.
Initial Engagement Costs
Our assessment services typically range from £2,400 to £4,200, whilst traditional consulting discovery phases often begin at £15,000 to £25,000. This difference reflects our focused approach and smaller team sizes.
Strategy development with us ranges from £5,500 to £9,000 compared to £30,000 to £60,000 for traditional consulting firms. We achieve comparable depth through efficient collaboration and targeted research.
Implementation Support Costs
Traditional consulting often separates strategy development from implementation support, creating additional large engagements. Our monthly support model at £3,200 provides flexibility to scale involvement up or down as your implementation progresses.
Over a typical six-month implementation period, this represents £19,200 compared to £40,000 to £80,000 for traditional implementation consulting.
Long-term Value Comparison
Because our approach builds internal capability, organisations typically reduce their consulting dependency more quickly. Clients report 40-60% reductions in ongoing consulting costs within twelve months as their teams develop competence in digital transformation management.
Traditional consulting relationships often create ongoing dependency, with annual consulting spend remaining consistent or increasing over time.
Total Cost of Ownership
When comparing total investment over two years including initial engagement, implementation support, and ongoing consulting needs, our approach typically delivers 30-50% cost savings whilst producing higher implementation success rates and stronger internal capability development.
What Working Together Looks Like
Traditional Client Experience
- • Limited access to senior consultants after initial meetings
- • Junior staff conduct most analysis and research
- • Formal presentations at milestone intervals
- • Deliverables provided at engagement conclusion
- • Implementation responsibility transitions to client
Our Client Experience
- • Direct access to experienced consultants throughout
- • Senior consultants conduct primary research with you
- • Weekly working sessions and continuous dialogue
- • Progressive deliverables with ongoing refinement
- • Optional implementation support and knowledge transfer
Transformation Journey Support
Digital transformation is a journey, not a project. Our approach recognises this by providing support that evolves as your needs change. Initial assessment and strategy work establishes direction, whilst ongoing implementation support helps you navigate challenges as they arise.
We measure success not by deliverables produced but by outcomes achieved and capabilities developed. This orientation keeps focus on what matters whilst maintaining flexibility to adjust approach as circumstances evolve.
Sustainability and Long-term Results
Sustainable digital transformation requires organisations to develop internal competence, not dependency on external consultants. Our methodology explicitly prioritises capability building, ensuring changes persist after our engagement concludes.
Six Months After Engagement
Traditional consulting clients often struggle with implementation as internal teams lack context and conviction about recommendations. Change initiatives may stall or be abandoned.
Our clients have typically completed 60-70% of prioritised initiatives with their internal teams leading implementation confidently.
Twelve Months After Engagement
Organisations working with traditional consultants may bring them back for implementation support or new projects, maintaining consulting dependency.
Our clients manage most digital transformation work internally, engaging us selectively for specific expertise or validation rather than primary guidance.
Lasting Impact Indicators
Organisations develop frameworks and processes they continue using independently. Teams apply methodologies learned during consulting engagements to new challenges without external support.
Digital maturity assessments conducted eighteen months after initial engagement typically show continued improvement, indicating sustained momentum rather than regression after consultant departure.
Internal staff who participated in consulting engagements often become organisational champions for digital transformation, spreading knowledge and maintaining focus on continuous improvement.
Measuring Sustained Change
We track client progress at six, twelve, and eighteen month intervals after engagement completion. This follow-up provides data on implementation persistence and allows us to refine our methodology based on long-term outcomes.
Organisations appreciate this continued interest in their success, and the data consistently shows that collaborative, capability-building approaches produce more durable results than traditional consulting models.
Addressing Common Misconceptions
"Larger firms have more resources and expertise"
Larger consulting firms do have extensive resources, but clients often work primarily with junior staff whilst paying for senior expertise. Smaller practices like ours provide direct access to experienced consultants throughout engagements. This can produce better outcomes at lower cost when the work requires deep expertise rather than large teams.
"Comprehensive documentation ensures thorough analysis"
Extensive documentation can create the appearance of thoroughness without ensuring implementability. Our focused approach prioritises actionable insights over comprehensive reporting. Clients receive the analysis they need to make decisions and move forward, without overwhelming documentation that often goes unread.
"Traditional consulting provides more rigorous methodology"
Rigour comes from appropriate application of analytical frameworks, not from lengthy processes. Our methodology applies proven assessment and strategy development frameworks efficiently. We achieve analytical rigour through experienced judgment about what analysis matters, not through comprehensive data collection that may include limited additional insight.
"Lower cost consulting means lower quality outcomes"
Our lower fees reflect different business economics, not different quality standards. We maintain lower overhead and work with smaller teams of senior consultants. This allows us to charge less whilst maintaining high standards. Quality should be judged by outcomes achieved and capability developed, not by fees charged.
Why Choose Our Approach
Our methodology suits organisations seeking practical support for digital transformation rather than extensive documentation or theoretical frameworks. If you value collaborative partnerships over expert pronouncements, implementation capability over comprehensive reporting, and sustainable change over quick fixes, our approach aligns with your needs.
When Our Approach Works Well
- ✓ You want to build internal digital transformation capability
- ✓ You value practical recommendations over comprehensive documentation
- ✓ You prefer collaborative partnerships to expert-client dynamics
- ✓ You seek cost-effective consulting without compromising quality
- ✓ You want consultants who remain accessible throughout engagements
Traditional consulting approaches serve important purposes and work well in certain contexts. Our goal is not to suggest they lack value, but to help you understand where different methodologies excel so you can make informed choices about which approach suits your situation.
Explore Whether Our Approach Fits Your Needs
We're happy to discuss your digital transformation challenges and help you determine whether our collaborative methodology aligns with your objectives and circumstances.
Arrange a Discussion